Rivet; A review
April 21, 2008
On Wednesday, Cynical Peak Software released Rivet, an application that allows you to share your media—music, videos, photos—from your Mac to an Xbox 360, opening your library to another device, and negating the need for an expensive Apple TV.
I heard of Rivet on Thursday from a PCWorld article linked from Hacker News. Rivet’s capabilities have been on my wish list for some time, and when I first heard of Connect360, a direct competitor to Rivet I was excited. However, my trial of Connect360 was rife with problems most notably awful connectivity (which has subsequently been chalked up to poor wireless coverage in our last place, so perhaps Connect360 deserves another chance). I had similar expectations of Rivet, however the demo allowed for 1 video and 10 songs played back per launch, so I decided to give it a shot.
My library includes a number of high-quality videos, generally around 1000kbps MP4 ripped from DVDs I own. The first test was to watch a short music video from my local hard drive on my MacBook Pro. It worked flawlessly; no skipping or stalling.
The second test was to attempt to stream a video from my Airport Extreme-mounted external hard drive, where the majority of my multimedia content is stored. My expectation was to see stalling while buffering the video, though that may have been explained by factors outside of the software. However, Rivet performed as intended once I restarted it to circumvent the 1-video-per-launch trial imposition.
Having established that video works well, I turned my sights to audio. Rivet uses the Xbox 360’s media center, which itself can be a hassle when traversing a library as extensive as mine. There are only a few views: Albums, Artists, Songs and Playlists. Searching is not possible, but this is a limitation of the Xbox 360, not of Rivet. Finding and playing music worked as expected, Rivet serving my iTunes library including my playlists. One feature I would like to see in audio is streaming radio. I listen to SomaFM for hours each day, using headphones to do so. Playing it through my Xbox 360 would be a better situation for me as I prefer my stereo over my headphones, despite how cool they look.
The last thing to test was the photo center. Rivet makes all photos in your iPhoto library available to your Xbox 360, including iPhoto events and albums. Again, this system utilizes the Xbox’s photo display so there is very little to say other than it works.
Rivet fools the Xbox into thinking your Mac is a PC, thereby allowing access to all your media. This functionality is enormously useful, with the ever-encroaching wane of DVDs and other physical media.
The drawbacks to the system are generally not drawbacks within Rivet itself, but within the Xbox, though they are certainly worth noting when considering the software.
The first is that it cannot play all formats. Media purchased from the iTunes store is not supported, nor are open formats such as ogg. The list of compatible formats is long, though, so one should be well-covered. From Cynical Peak’s site: “If your Xbox 360 can play it, Rivet can handle it.”
The other drawback is that your computer must be on and running Rivet to play any media. This is so even if you have an external hard drive on the network, though again this is a limitation of the Xbox, not Rivet. Rivet is simply the gateway, and a damn good one.
Rivet is a good tool for its use, and it even allows for configurable directories for media serving. This means that if you have media outside of your iTunes playlist you can simply add the directory and Rivet will display the media on your Xbox in the same fashion.
An additional nicety is that Rivet stays in your taskbar menu bar, not the Dock; out of sight, out of mind.
In the end it took me about 15 minutes to decide to purchase Rivet. It has fantastic performance and options, without cost to your computer’s performance, all for a mere $18.95. You can save an additional 10% by completing the short survey that is displayed after the initial download, bringing your price to only $17.05.
It’s not often that I spend money on software, but products like Rivet that show an unrivaled level of polish make the decision easy. I want it to work without hassle, and Rivet delivers just that.
Add your comment
No HTML; Only URLs and line breaks are converted.
Comments
Congrats on being linked by Gruber.
Posted by Harish
I've been using Connect360 for awhile now, and it is very good. My only gripe with it is that all videos get dumped into 1 large folder. I Haven't tried Rivet yet, but I've read that all the videos stay nicely in their own folders, which is a bonus.
Posted by Matt
You definitely will want to try Connect360 again. It works great, and fixes are very quick when the 360 has its bi-annual Dashboard updates. The functionality and ease you describe with Rivet is also in Connect360 (minus the folder structure). That said, media runs smoothly and without issue.
It is good, however, to have a competitor, although functionality of these programs is likely limited by the Xbox and not software designers, and both are likely maxed out (or close to it) in terms of providing what the 360 will allow them to provide.
Posted by e:leaf
The one thing they could do (but don't) is transcode non-recognized media on the fly.
The only difference between Connect360 and rivet is a few folder structure items, functionality is the same otherwise.
Posted by Alex
It would be nice if either of them flattened files. Meaning if you have Movie.cd1 and Movie.cd2 It would show just as Movie In the list view. XBMC does this so im not sure if its even possible with Rivert or Connect 360.
Alex, they have more differences then you listed.
Rivet allows you to hide the itunes movie and iphoto movies from your movie view. Connect 360 doesn't.
Rivet allows you to add folders outside the movies folders not so with connect
Also Rivet updates in real time. I have always had to close 360 and open it to see new movies added to my movies folder
As a side note anyone know how to wake up the mac from the xbox 360? If its sleeping?
Posted by Jason
"An additional nicety is that Rivet stays in your taskbar, not the Dock; out of sight, out of mind."
Huh? I thought Rivet was a Mac program. Windows has the Taskbar, Mac OS X has the Dock. I'm confused about what you're saying here.
Posted by Mr. Man
Jason
-Connect 360 can share any folder you like for Movies, but only 1 at a time. Rivet wins there.
-Realtime updates were an issue early on, but I find current software is extremely fast to acknowledge new additions.
Jared
-Connect360 support Internet Radio through iTunes I think.
I find Connect360 very reliable, and the developer is very responsive. The only point lacking is folder structure - but I think I was told that is coming. Nice to see some decent competition in this area.
Posted by Angus
@Mr Man: Updated to say "menu bar".
Posted by SuperJared
Connect 360 does streaming audio (MP3) when I select a stream I have placed in a playlist. My biggest gripes about C360 is that it does not respect eh (do not show unchecked) option for podcasts - and they way it displays all podcasts and videos - many titles are not sufficient to determine what podcast it is or what the episode order is. I am looking at the ?TV just so that I can have an intelligible interface.
Posted by RM
As I was looking into Rivet a new version of Connect360 was released with all the features Rivet claims make it better. I really didn't like how Connect360 grouped all the movies together, but it's now fixed. I'm sticking with Connect360.
Posted by Jason
i like your work ty.
Posted by jhustine rhoy
Does anyone know if Rivet plays video in surround sound? Right now, Connect 360 only plays in stereo, which sucks! Does anyone have a work around for Connect in the audio department?
Posted by Simon
Connect 360 had plenty of time to get their act together. I just switched to Rivet since Connect 360 is now the one playing catch-up.
It's all about usability on your Xbox... and Rivet wins hands down.
Rivet:
- iTunes is organized with folder structure
- You can add more than one directory for movies
- Directory structure is maintained in XBox 360
- Access Control List
Posted by Craig
If you can get MY RIVET to work than it is a miracle. This program blows my balls so far.. email hsample@socal.rr.com
ichat:okimonacomputer
Posted by Hayden